Best Winter Pool Covers Review Guide 2023

Best Winter Pool Covers Review Guide 2023 It’s important to take measures to protect your pool, when winter comes around and you are no longer using your pool for a while. When we did our research we found winter pool covers come in a variety of sizes and shapes. You’ll need to buy yours to fit your pool perfectly no way around it. These winter pool covers are very important during the fall and winter months by protecting your expensive pool from from various weather elements. Having one of these winter pool covers this winter will not only protect your pool from dirt, debris, and algae. Also like leaves in the fall and twigs in the winter throughout the winter months.

The UV resistant material keeps sunlight and contaminants out of you pool, preserving your pool water while reducing the need for chemical application. The covers are designed to be incredibly durable w/ heavy duty heat treated seams ensuring you pool is ready for the next season.

The problem comes in with choosing just the right winter pool cover among the different ones available in the market today. We have solved that problem with our Best Winter Pool Covers Review Guide 2023. Showcasing only the best winter pool covers to make an easier selection for you. We have also individually reviewed each product to help you make a well-researched purchase.

Best Winter Pool Covers Buyers Guide 2023

Product FAQ:

What are Winter Pool Covers?

Winter pool covers are usually waterproof and made from solid materials. They keep your pool safe to be used next summer season by helping to winterize your pool against the elements. They also provide added features such as not allowing leaves, debris to fall into your pool and algae also.

What Does It Do?

If you live in a place prone to rain, sleet or snow winter season can be harsh on your pool. These winter covers help protect the interior of your pool when there is no water in it, also the pool titles. Empty pools also pose a safety hazard as there is always a risk of someone falling in especially children and pets.

How Does It Work?
Winter pool covers work by completely covering your swimming pool. The material is strong enough to protect your pool in any season and withstand climatic shifts. Also as mentioned above it acts as a precautionary cover to prevent someone from accidentally falling into an empty pool.

Should A Winter Pool Cover Touch Water?

In situations where you receive a heavy snowfall your pool water level should not be too low, as the water must support the cover. Ideally, at the same time, you don’t want the water to touch the underside of the cover under general conditions as that contact will create a wet spot where debris will accumulate.

Do You Really Need To Cover Your Pool The Winter?

No, but winter covers protect your pool from poor water balance, stains, and algae growth, that could damage pool surfaces. Winter pool covers block both debris and sunlight, to conserve your winter chemicals and protect soft and shiny surfaces.

Can I Use A Tarp As A Winter Pool Cover?

An obvious solution is to cover the pool when it’s not in use to keep out foreign material, but custom-made swimming pool covers can be quite expensive. An alternative option, much less expensive, is to use a large plastic or vinyl tarp, secured at the corners with tent stakes and bungee cords. But if you can afford a winter pool cover we highly recommend using that instead of a tarp.

WaterWarden Winter Pool Cover 

Safeguard your in-ground pool & protect it from the harsh winter in one easy step with the Water Warden mesh winter pool cover. Every Water Warden winter pool cover is manufactured in adherence to strict quality standards. They are designed & engineered the “old-fashioned” way, with no shortcuts, cutting corners or materials substitutions. Every Water Warden cover features top-of-the-line, Complete 2-Ply strap webbing throughout the cover, for unparalleled strength. The fine, lightweight mesh material allows rain to seep through into the pool but screens out leaves, twigs & other debris.
This ensures that the spring opening of your pool is easier & more convenient. Available in a variety of sizes & step configurations to best meet your needs.

This pool safety cover comes in a variety of standard pool sizes in a rectangle shape. It comes with all hardware such as hooks, springs and solid brass anchors. It also comes with an installation tool to make the whole process easier and streamlined. The winter cover can be installed and removed from the pool in just minutes. This winter pool cover is lightweight and very easy to store. The anchors recess flush into pool deck. They do not interfere with pool use as well. The winter cover is triple stitched and double strapped from top to bottom to provide a second layer of protection. Proudly made in the USA.

Product Features:

• Solid brass anchors recess flush into the pool deck and don’t interfere with pool use during summer months
• All hardware, including solid brass anchors, hooks, springs and installation tool included
• Safety cover system installs on your pool and removes in minutes (after initial installation)
• Generous 2′ overlap ensures complete coverage; pool size 20′ x 38′ – cover size 22′ x 40′
• Break-strength of over 4,000 lbs.

From The Manufacturer:

Double Strapping
WaterWarden Means Safe
All WaterWarden safety covers are triple-stiched and double strapped top and bottom throughout. Double-strapping adds a second layer of protection and durability.

Reinforced X-Tacking Where the straps cross each other on the edges of every cover, we apply X-Tack stitching for extra reinforcement and safety.

 

 

Hardware
Heavy Duty Hardware Kit Included WaterWarden covers include heavy duty hardware kits. The components are made out of finely crafted materials, including solid brass, stainless steel and heavy-duty aluminum. WaterWarden D-Ring Springs are designed to eliminate the need for buckles.

Customers Comments:

None at this time

PROS

• Heavy duty hardware kit
• Center drain
• Easy to install

CONS

• Runs small
• Poor light defense

Rectangle Loop-Loc Winter Pool Cover

This cover is large with 2 feet extra material to cover your pool size properly which is a good thing. The pool cover comes with a dense feature with a legendary ultra-strong mesh. It prevents the formation of algae and blocks almost all sunlight. To prevent sagging in the cover the mesh allows melting snow and rain to drain through. So if your a pool owner that does not want sunlight or debris falling on their pool water this would be a good choice for you.

Product Features:

• 20 x 40 Rectangle Loop-Loc Safety Pool Cover
• Size Listed is Pool Size – Cover will be 2′ larger
• All hardware for cement installation included

Customers Comments:

• Quality Cover
• Five Stars
• GREAT CUSTOMER SERVICE
• Very good cover, but pricey compared with the competition

PROS

• Strong and sturdy mesh
• No debris falling into the pool
• Prevent algae buildup

CONS

• Expensive

Meyco Swimming Pool Winter Cover

Light enough to put on or remove from swimming pools in minutes! This Durable, long-lasting Meyco safety cover is
strong enough to support your entire family. Many pool owners use these safety pool covers during the swimming season because they are so easy to use, as well as during the winter months! You won’t have any accidental drowning with this winter cover, rest assured your pets and kids will be safe.

The Meyco swimming pool cover is crafted from super-strong, two-ply Meycolite mesh with a break strength of more than 4,000 lbs. Resists mildew, chlorine damage, sunlight, and rot. Held in place with Meyco’s time-tested spring-loaded brass Pop-Up anchoring system during use. When not in use this system recesses flush with your deck. Meyco pool covers provide excellent winter protection in addition to its superior safety features. Its fine, lightweight mesh screens out most leaves and debris but still allows rain to seep through. Meyco pool winter covers are a long-term investment in protection, safety, and peace of mind.

Each safety cover comes complete with the spring-loaded brass Pop-Up anchoring system, stainless-steel buckles and springs, installation tool and heavy-duty storage bag. Initial installation of anchors will require a rotary hammer drill and 3/4 inch drill bit. ASTM rated. 12 year
warranty. The cover is forest green.

Product Features:

• Crafted from super-strong, two-ply Meycolite mesh with a break strength of more than 4,000 lbs
• Resists rot, mildew, sunlight and chlorine damage
• Cover is held in place with Meyco’s time-tested spring-loaded brass Pop-Up anchoring system
• Mesh allows rain to seep through, but screens out leaves and debris
• The cover is forest green

Customers Comments:

None At This Time

PROS:

• Super strong mesh
• Debris Preventiono
• Effective rainage
• 12 year warranty

CONS:

• Difficult to install

Pool Mate 573060R Sandstone Winter Pool Cover

The cover fabric is made of professional quality polyethylene. The Pool Mate Sandstone In-Ground Pool Winter Cover protects your pool during harsh winter conditions. Throughout the winter this professional-quality, polyethylene cover blocks out any debris and dirt. In the winter months the Sandstone Cover prevents algae growth by blocking UV rays from entering your pool. If you buy this winter pool cover and close your pool with the proper winterizing chemicals you will have not only a clean pool in the spring you’ll find that it will also be easy to open. It is always recommended to open your pool by mid to late May. Overlap is additional material beyond the size of your pool. And this winter cover features a 5-foot overlap. You will need to order by pool size and then add to the length and or width if you have a buddy-seat or pool steps.

The cover should be able to float comfortably on the water. Includes water tube loops only to be used with water tubes, which is sold separately. This high-quality, lightweight cover with heat sealed seams is built to last a long time. In fact the Pool Mate Sandstone In-Ground Pool Winter Cover comes with a 12 year warranty.

Product Features:

• Professional-quality, polyethylene
• Stops algae growth
• 5-foot overlap for easy installation
• All seams are heat sealed for better performance
• 12 year warranty

Customers Comments:

• Great for pool
• Not a bad price and looks good.
• Appears to be a good product.
• Thinner material then our old one and no grommets for

PROS:

• 12-year warranty
• Lightweight
• Generous sized

CONS:

• No anchors or grommets

YARD GUARD DG183658S Winter Pool Cover

Protect your pool from the elements with a high quality mesh winter cover. The Yard Guard 18 x 36 Feet With 8 Feet Center End Steps Pool Winter Cover is constructed with tight, porous mesh that keeps out debris and silt while allowing pool water to flow right through it. This winter cover is constructed to withstand years of wear and tear. The webbing of every seam is reinforced on the top and bottom. Also the the rub strips on the seams protect your pool surface. The mesh resists mildew, UV rays, rot and damage from harsh pool water.

This winter pool cover is built using the most modern cover technology with a computerized shaping and cutting system. Verified by a Computer Aided System. If you want a winter pool cover that’s quality checked and will last you years, the Yard Guard pool cover is a safe bet.

Product Features:

• High-quality in-ground pool safety cover with porous, tight mesh that keeps out silt and debris
• Resistant to rot, mildew, UV, and damage caused by pool water
• White thread is triple-stitched at all perimeter stress points
• Straps run on both top and bottom of the cover for added strength
• Reinforced webbing on the top and bottom of every seam

Customers Comments:

• Seem to be well constructed.
• Great value
• It was very easy to install and it appears to be a very high-quality cover.

PROS:

• Easy to install
• Prevents Debris
• UV protection

CONS:

• had to tighten the straps several times
• Ok but not perfect

Conclusion:

Before buying a winter pool cover for your pool it’s very important to know you requirements and pool size. The ones we’ve reviewed here, are all good, however, they do differ based on their functionality. The Pool Winter Cover by Water Warden is the one we would recommend if your looking for an easy install winter pool cover. All the winter pool covers reviewed here are of high quality and are of good value for the money. With that said we hope this Best Winter Pool Covers Review Guide 2023 will help you make an informed decision on your next winter pool cover.